2560 May Road, Galway, NY 12086, Galway

DO NOT CONTACT WE ARE RELISTING IN THE SPRING!! — Welcome to Pine Hollow, a year-round sanctuary on Galway Lake with 144′ of pristine frontage. Set on a rare .44-acre lot, this custom-crafted home is one of the few true four-season residences on the lake. Thoughtfully renovated in 2005 and lovingly enhanced ever since, it blends rustic charm with whimsical character—knotty pine walls, wide-plank floors, stained glass, and a custom hobbit-style door. Nearly every room offers serene lake views.
The main kitchen features handcrafted tile, a Dutch door, and locally sourced custom wood countertops. The walkout lower level offers a full eat-in second kitchen with matching custom wood countertops, a new half bath, and a cozy wood-burning fireplace—ideal for guests or multi-generational living.
Enjoy 3 stone patios, 3 terraced decks (including a new 2024 lower deck), a fire pit, private dock, and swimming platform. Additional highlights: boat shed, 12-person cedar picnic table, perennial gardens, potting shed, Andersen windows, custom closets, cedar closet, EV charger, ADT security system, and water treatment system.
Located on a non-motorized (electric allowed) lake—perfect for paddling, swimming, and unplugged living—Pine Hollow is more than a home; it’s a place to slow down, reconnect, and make lasting memories.